As you write "discovered in another cell," I infer that the "list of winners" is entered in one cell. With that cell as A1, then try a formula like this in C3:
=IF(ISERR(SEARCH(C2,A1)),"",C1)
If the "list of winners" is actually in a range of cells, with each winning team name in its own cell (which is a more natural way to represent a list in Excel, then use a lookup function, e.g. if the list of winners is in the cells A1 through A10:
=IF(ISNA(MATCH(C2,A1:A10,0)),"",C1)